As the holiday season rolls in, countless spirited debates spark over which classic Christmas movie truly takes the crown. While we all know the iconic titles that fill the airwaves—think “It’s a Wonderful Life,” “Home Alone,” or “Love Actually”—there are also those delightful films that teeter on the edge of holiday themes yet often fly under the radar. This year, why not explore beyond the usual favorites, leaving “A Christmas Story” and “White Christmas” on the shelf?
The Associated Press Film Writers, Jake Coyle and Lindsey Bahr, have curated a list of fantastic Christmas films to match every mood you might find yourself in this season.
A Film That Feels Festive But Isn’t Necessarily a Christmas Movie
“Grand Budapest Hotel”: Aside from its sprinkling of snow, Wes Anderson’s 2014 gem doesn’t explicitly scream Christmas. Yet, if you’re looking for a movie that mirrors the joy of unwrapping a gift, this one is unbeatable. Delve into Anderson’s elaborate aesthetics and whimsical narratives, and you’re bound to grin. (Available for digital rental) — Coyle
The Ideal Film for a Touch of Elegance
“Metropolitan” (1990): Who hasn’t fantasized about a glamorous debutante season in New York? Whit Stillman’s “Metropolitan” captures a group of privileged youths navigating this world, making it the perfect pick for those wishing for a taste of sophistication without the need for tuxedos and formal gowns. (Available on Criterion, MAX, Hulu, and Prime Video) — Bahr
A Standout Performance Amidst Felt Characters
“A Muppets Christmas Carol” (1992): While many have adapted Dickens, few can match Michael Caine’s Oscar-worthy portrayal of Ebenezer Scrooge alongside beloved Muppets. Caine shines even in a cast filled with characters like Beaker and Dr. Bunsen Honeydew, while Gonzo and Rizzo the Rat provide a memorable performance as well. (Available on Disney+) — Coyle
The Emotional Christmas Tearjerker
“The Umbrellas of Cherbourg” (1964): Although Jacques Demy’s vibrant musical isn’t set solely during Christmas, that poignant final scene at a snowy gas station evokes enough emotion to resonate during the holidays. The enchanting visuals and Catherine Deneuve’s charming apparel perfectly complement Michel Legrand’s evocative musical score, making it a fitting choice for festive viewing. (Streaming on The Criterion Channel) — Bahr
The Ultimate Los Angeles Christmas Movie
“Kiss Kiss Bang Bang”: While traditional holiday films may not feature a fast-talking Robert Downey Jr., Shane Black’s 2005 neo-noir comedy is a refreshing option worth revisiting each year. Set against the backdrop of Christmas in Los Angeles, it humorously subverts festive norms with a plot about a thief turned actor amid the city’s seedy underbelly. (Available for digital rental) — Coyle
A Whimsical House-Swapping Fantasy
“The Holiday” (2006): While the charming English cottage may not exist, the film’s premise is absolutely delightful. From romantic plotlines to memorable scenes, including Cameron Diaz’s dash through the snowy countryside in elegant heels, Nancy Meyers crafts a delightful rom-com that wears its heart on its sleeve. The film manages to pay homage to the classics, showcasing everything from the meet-cute moment to Eli Wallach’s enchanting lessons. (Streaming on Hulu and Prime Video) — Bahr
A Unique Christmas Thriller
“Three Days of the Condor”: Sydney Pollack’s 1975 spy thriller revisits Christmas as a mere backdrop with Robert Redford and Faye Dunaway navigating suspenseful machinations. In questioning the notions of togetherness during the holidays, this cleverly woven story resonates profoundly in today’s climate. (Streaming on Paramount+) — Coyle
The Best Contemporary Christmas Film for Kids
“Klaus”: With many lackluster holiday films flooding the market, Sergio Pablos’ 2019 animated Netflix feature stands out as an origin story for Santa Claus, narrated through the lens of a postman in a secluded northern village. It serves as a love letter to the season, highlighting the key role of the postal service in festive cheer. (Streaming on Netflix) — Coyle
Perfect for the Youngest Audience
“Shaun the Sheep: The Flight Before Christmas” (2021): With a runtime of merely 30 minutes, this charming film is ideal for your littlest viewers. It’s adorable, humorous, and filled with adventure with a gentle touch—perfectly non-scary for little ones who might worry about flying sleighs or culinary mishaps. (Streaming on Netflix) — Bahr
Best Overall Holiday Movie
“Nobody’s Fool”: Directed by Robert Benton and based on a Richard Russo adaptation, this 1994 film starring Paul Newman spans the time from Thanksgiving to New Year’s Eve, encompassing Christmas along the way. Though it transcends the holiday, its heartwarming exploration of small-town life and long-held regrets will resonate just as deeply as any traditional holiday flick, thanks in part to standout performances from its talented cast, including a memorable Bruce Willis and a young Philip Seymour Hoffman. (Streaming on Kanopy and available for digital rental) — Coyle
For Vintage Charm and Heartbreak
“Carol” (2015): Even if Cate Blanchett’s character hadn’t enchanted Rooney Mara while wearing a Santa hat in a New York department store, Todd Haynes’ “Carol” would still stand out as an exquisitely crafted holiday film. It masterfully weaves themes of love, heartache, and mid-century style, presenting a poignant romantic narrative amid the backdrop of the Christmas season. (Streaming on Netflix, Paramount+, and MUBI) — Bahr
The Classic TCM Holiday Film
“Christmas in Connecticut” (1945): While it’s not necessary to catch this screwball classic starring Barbara Stanwyck on TCM, it certainly fits right in. The story follows a columnist who creates a fictitious persona as a perfect homemaker, which becomes difficult to sustain when her boss insists on spending Christmas with her. Its underlying premise—that the idyllic holiday is a myth—adds to its enduring charm. (Streaming on WatchTCM) — Coyle
For a Touch of 19th Century New England
“Little Women” (1994 and 2019): Both Gillian Armstrong’s and Greta Gerwig’s versions of “Little Women” evoke a distinctly festive vibe. The wintery scenes of the March family, laden with Christmas spirit, hearthside cheer, and familial warmth, resonate with the essence of the holiday season. While both adaptations have their merits, you can enjoy the nostalgia of the 1994 film or soak in the modern flair of Gerwig’s interpretation. (1994 version available for digital rental; 2019 streaming on Hulu) — Bahr
The Quintessential Christmas Movie
“The Shop Around the Corner” (1940): While you might argue for other beloved Christmas movies starring Jimmy Stewart, Ernst Lubitsch’s romantic classic remains a timeless love story that surpasses them all. Its perfect blend of charm, wit, and a hint of darkness creates an unforgettable viewing experience—plus, it lends itself well to a fun drinking game where you sip every time “Mr. Matuschek” is mentioned. (Streaming on WatchTCM and Max) — Coyle
“Miracle on 34th Street” (1947): It may not be groundbreaking, but George Seaton’s heartwarming classic remains the epitome of a Christmas movie. Strikingly contemporary for its time, the film depicts a spirited single mother, a skeptical child, and a litigious approach to holiday cheer, all wrapped in a story that is ultimately filled with hope. Following the journey from Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade to Christmas Day, it encapsulates the quintessence of the holiday spirit. (Streaming on Disney+, Hulu, and Prime Video) — Bahr
